top of page

Forget Fad Diets: They Belong in the Bin

Updated: Jan 14

A woman with lettuce in her mouth looking perplexed

Let’s talk about fad diets - the smooth-talking scammers of the nutrition world. They promise everything: fast results, effortless weight loss, and a “healthier, happier you.” But the reality? They trap you in a soul-crushing cycle of restriction, guilt, and frustration. Lose weight, gain it back, repeat. Sound familiar?


And they don’t just mess with your body - they get inside your head. Suddenly, you’re convinced you need a list of forbidden foods to be healthy. You feel guilty for eating a slice of toast or enjoying dessert. You catch yourself obsessing over numbers on a scale or calorie tracker. All because some diet plan told you that’s how it has to be.


Here’s the truth: the problem isn’t you. It’s the diet. Fad diets are designed to fail. They set you up for frustration and self-doubt so you keep coming back for more. Enough is enough - it’s time to kick them where they belong: in the bin.


Why Fad Diets Don’t Work


Fad diets are built on extremes. They ban foods, demonize carbs, or tell you to eat like a caveman. And while these rules might seem logical at first, they’re impossible to stick to long-term.


When you inevitably slip up - because life happens - they make you feel like a failure. Cue the spiral: “I’ve ruined everything. I may as well give up.” Sound familiar? That’s the diet talking.


Even worse, fad diets can wreck your relationship with food. They take something natural and joyful - eating - and turn it into a source of stress. Suddenly, food isn’t just food; it’s a moral dilemma.


Red Flags to Watch For


How do you spot a fad diet? Simple: if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Watch out for:


  • Banned food lists (like “no carbs” or “no sugar”).

  • Extreme calorie cuts that leave you starving.

  • Generic, one-size-fits-all plans.

  • Promises of rapid results without the effort.


These aren’t solutions - they’re traps.


What About Your Relationship With Food?


Even if you’ve sworn off diets, you might still be dealing with the leftovers. Obsessively counting calories? Feeling guilty after eating? That’s diet culture whispering in your ear.


Here’s how to check in with yourself:


  • Do you constantly worry about your weight or food choices?

  • Do you feel the need to “make up” for eating with extra exercise?

  • Do you label foods as “good” or “bad”?


If any of this sounds familiar, it’s time to rethink your relationship with food.


How to Build a Healthier Relationship With Food


Eating guilt-free isn’t about what’s on your plate - it’s about what’s in your head.


  1. Remove Food Labels: Stop calling food “good” or “bad.” Food is just food. The only reason you feel guilty is because you’ve attached morality to your choices. Let that go.


  2. Give Yourself Permission: The secret to eating without guilt? Granting yourself permission to enjoy all foods. Yes, even chocolate and pizza. When you stop forbidding yourself, you stop overeating out of rebellion.


  3. Practice Kindness: Nobody’s perfect, and that includes you. If you slip up, don’t beat yourself up. Progress is about consistency, not perfection.


And most importantly: start seeing food as more than fuel or calories. It’s also joy, culture, connection, and pleasure.


Practical Steps to Start Today


Here’s how to put this into practice:


  • Choose one “forbidden” food and eat it guilt-free this week (give yourself permission in the first place).

  • Take a break from tracking calories or macros. Focus instead on eating when you’re hungry and stopping when you’re satisfied.

  • Write down three things you enjoy about food - like a favorite meal or the way it brings people together.


These small shifts might not seem like much, but over time, they’ll transform the way you think about eating.


Forget Perfection


Here’s the real deal about lasting progress: it’s not about being perfect. It’s about showing up every day (or most days!) and doing your best. Some days, that’s a chicken salad and a gym session. Other days, it’s a chocolate bar and a nap. Both are okay.


Real success comes from patience, consistency, and balance - not extremes. Forget the fads. Forget the guilt. Focus on finding what works for you.


What’s Next?


There’s so much more to unpack about food, freedom, and feeling good in your own skin. What’s holding you back? What’s confusing you? Let me know - I’d love to tackle the topics that matter most to you in future blogs.


For now, start small. Take one step to move away from restriction and toward balance. It could be as simple as enjoying a slice of cake without guilt or skipping the calorie tracker for a day. These moments build confidence - and confidence builds lasting change.


You don’t need a perfect plan. You just need permission to embrace a healthier, happier way of eating - one that fits your life, fuels your goals, and feels good.


The best time to start? Right now.




 

About Karen

gym owner Karen Coghlan standing in Freedom Fitness and smiling

Hi, I’m Karen, owner of Freedom Fitness and nutrition coach. I’m here to help you build a healthier, more balanced relationship with food and fitness - one that fits your life, not someone else’s rules.



Got questions or want to chat about your goals? Drop a comment below, or get in touch.

42 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page